READINESS FOR PARTICIPATORY EVALUATION

by Ricardo Ramírez & Joaquín Navas

‘Readiness’ is an English language term that is difficult to translate into Spanish as it encompasses various themes: preparation, availability, propensity, timeliness, agility, competency, willingness – among others.  In the Spanish version of this entry, we use ‘availability’ (‘disposición’) with the understanding that it covers the other themes. In the field of evaluation, readiness is foremost across the first two steps of Utilization-focused Evaluation (UFE) as proposed by Michael Quinn Patton (2008). Readiness is also referenced in other fields, for instance in communication strategy design (Ramelan, 2014).

While the goal of UFE is the actual use of evaluation, the approach relies on the direct participation of ‘evaluation users’; it is their direct engagement that provides them with a sense of ownership over the process and the findings. In other words, UFE confirm that it is very much part of other collaborative approaches to evaluation (Ramírez & Brodhead, 2020).

Continue reading

Key Stakeholder Mapping: A Tool for Understanding Social Complexity

THE EVALPARTICIPATIVA PODCAST

The EvalParticipativa Podcast is a space for dialogue, exchange, and articulation within the Community of Practice and Learning in Participatory Evaluation in Latin America. It is conceived as a platform to strengthen collective learning, make situated experiences visible, and promote an approach to evaluation that is collaboratively constructed and grounded in local territories.

Each episode invites leading figures in participatory evaluation from the region to share not only their technical expertise and professional trajectories, but also their motivations, experiences, and personal journeys. In this way, evaluation is presented as a living practice, deeply connected to specific contexts, social processes, and the histories of those who carry it forward. The podcast seeks to build bridges between reflection and action, between expert knowledge and practice-based knowledge, reinforcing an inclusive and critical perspective committed to the use of evaluation for learning, improvement, and social transformation.

Continue reading

DESIGNS AND METHODS FOR IMPACT ASSESSMENT

by Pablo Rodríguez Bilella

Over the past two decades, the movement aimed at achieving evidence-based policies has gained importance and prominence. It holds that policymakers should base their decisions on the best available evidence regarding “what works,” rather than on ideologies or in response to particular interests.

One of its assumptions is that not all evidence has been rigorous enough to provide certainty in decision-making. This accentuated the orientation toward supporting certain approaches and methodologies that, given their rigorous formulation, would lead to superior results. This general context has favored debate and discussion on impact evaluation from different spheres and spaces (political, academic, social, etc.).

Continue reading

ICONOCLASISTAS: an invitation to collective creation for understanding processes of change and transformation

DEVICES FOR COLLABORATIVE RESEARCH, ITINERANT COLLECTIVE MAPPING, CRITICAL CARTOGRAPHIES AND PEDAGOGICAL RESOURCES FOR COMMUNITY USE

by Pablo Ares and Julia Risler

Iconoclasistas was born in 2006 as a space that brings together graphic art, activism, critical pedagogy and collective working methodologies. Since then, the initiative has consolidated as a device that combines visual poetics, political reflection and critical pedagogies, always incorporating the environmental dimension.

We see ourselves as activists, though not in the partisan or institutional sense. We understand our practice as a militancy of doing, sustained through networks, ties and affections activated from the body, the territory and collaborative practices. We recognise ourselves as part of a broad and dynamic fabric made up of collectives, social movements and organised communities, articulated more by political, ethical, aesthetic and environmental affinities than by rigid structures.

Continue reading

Outcome Harvesting for Participatory Monitoring: A Conversation Between Colleagues

By Giovanna Montagner and Carmen Wilson-Grau

Outcome Harvesting is a participatory method used to identify, formulate, analyze, and learn from the changes brought about by an intervention, especially when cause-effect relationships are complex or unknown.

Rather than focusing on predefined objectives, it looks at what has actually changed and how the program contributed to those changes. This method emphasizes utilization, enabling evaluators, donors, and project/program managers to identify, formulate, verify, and make sense of the outcomes of an intervention.

This method brought us together. We met in 2019, when Giovanna, after attending a training on Outcome Harvesting, contacted Carmen to practice with her. Since then, we’ve kept up the habit of having virtual coffee chats every now and then. Today, we’ve come together to talk about Carmen’s experience using Outcome Harvesting for monitoring.

Continue reading

Storytelling and Social Transformation: The Voice of David Noundji from Cameroon

Storytelling is a universal human practice that has accompanied us throughout history. Through narrative, cultures communicate, educate and entertain — but they also transmit values, knowledge and collective memory. While it may seem simple, storytelling is a complex art that has evolved over time and continues to adapt to contemporary contexts and challenges.

With the aim of exploring these transformations and strengthening storytelling capacities, at the beginning of 2025 we launched the series INVISIBLE STORIES MADE VISIBLE: STORYTELLING IN AFRICA. This initiative brings together artists, scholars and communities to share experiences, techniques and approaches to storytelling. It offers a space where storytelling intersects with participatory evaluation and knowledge communication.

Continue reading

EVALUATION EXPEDITION: THE INTERVENTION FOREST

A game to evaluate the quality and performance of an intervention

by Vanesa Castro

The Evaluation Expedition is a participatory tool that invites all stakeholders involved in a project to go on a journey through a symbolic forest which represents the complexity of an intervention. Along this journey, participants must respond to key questions that allow them to engage in a comprehensive reflection, dialogue and evaluation of their intervention.

We present here this new creation of EvalParticipativa, a game that promotes a collaborative atmosphere in which every voice is heard and valued, and in which the active participation of everyone is essential for learning and continual improvement of our interventions.

Continue reading

PROJECT TRAFFIC LIGHTS

An ex-ante evaluation game to analyse project feasibility and guide redesigns

by Esteban Tapella

In this article I’ll present a tool designed jointly with Vanesa Castro and Valeria Sarmiento, members of the EvalParticipativa team, which was designed to help players participate in the review and critical analysis of a project, addressing the variables or feasibility factors that are most relevant to the intervention in question.

The game is played by representatives from the target group or population, support entity members, donor representatives etc. Their participation should be open and non-hierarchical as they review and critically reflect on a completed project design that is ready for implementation.

Continue reading

Questions that matter. The tool “What Shall we Evaluate?”

By Juan Carlos Sanz and Esteban Tapella

The order of events in participatory evaluation does not stray far from that used in conventional evaluation. And yet, there are some clearly differentiating elements and steps that we need to be aware of if we want more actors to participate.

The planning phase is particularly relevant. At this stage, the evaluation team identifies which actors are going to participate in the process; determines the topics and questions which the evaluation intends to answer; selects where and how the necessary information will be gathered; creates spaces for reviewing and analysing the data; establishes the best formats for communicating the evaluation results; and chooses the most appropriate mechanisms to ensure that these results are put to use. The work plan also specifies the timeframe for the evaluation and estimates what resources will be necessary for its implementation.

Continue reading

THE ‘PERIODIC TABLE’ OF EVALUATION

by Sara Vaca

Evaluation is a vast field of designs and methods in continuous development. The numerous parameters and choices associated with different methodological options can be difficult to fully understand without deep study and desk review.

The motivation for the Periodic Table of Evaluation was to create a one-pager visual that catalogues methodological options and parameters involved in an evaluation design.

Continue reading