Different methods of storytelling in Africa. The ‘story tellers’ and their perspectives.

At the beginning of 2024 we shared the article “The arrival of the two rivers. Scientific storytelling”, in which we analyzed the role of stories rooted in each community when it comes to linking scientific advances and the dissemination of knowledge with the work of local populations, their culture and their impact on research and -why not!- the evaluative field.

In September of the same year we reported on the lessons learned from the Retreat on Storytelling and Participatory Evaluation, that was held in Limbe, Cameroon, organized together with eBASE AFRICA. During this meeting we documented and socialized the rich African traditions of storytelling and its contribution to participatory approaches in evaluation.

Continue reading →

QUESTION DICE. A TOOL TO HELP PEOPLE TALK ABOUT THEIR PROJECTS

by Juan Murciano

Hello community EvalParticipativa. In this post, I will present a tool that has been designed to help people talk about their projects by answering important questions that underpin their intervention’s Theory of Change (ToC).

What is a Theory of Change?

A project’s ToC is a collection of ideas that, on the one hand, seeks to explain the different reasons why an intervention is necessary, and on the other, describes how this intervention is going to solve the problems that have been prioritised. It is a detailed description of how and why the project designers think a project or programme will produce specific changes or impacts. It includes an analysis of the contexts, assumptions, interventions and impacts that are expected in the long-term.

Continue reading →

INCORPORATING PARTICIPATION IN PERFORMANCE EVALUATION

Lessons from a Mexican programme providing financial assistance for individuals with permanent disabilities

by Karen Azucena Hernández González

The ideas I share in this post are largely based on my experience working as an analyst and consultant in the 2018 evaluation of the Mexican Pensión para el Bienestar de las Personas con Discapacidad Permanente (Financial assistance to promote the wellbeing of individuals with permanent disabilities; hereafter PBPDP as per its abbreviation in Spanish) during its first year of implementation. This social programme is aimed at people with permanent disabilities aged between 0 and 29 years; Afro-Mexicans with permanent disabilities aged between 30 and 64; and people with permanent disabilities that live in severely marginalised areas (ROP, 2021).

As a young evaluator in the evaluation team, I had the opportunity to familiarise myself with the programme, conduct fieldwork and play a role in its respective analysis. While there was no explicit request in the project’s terms of reference to include a gender, intercultural or intersectional perspective, I was able to identify spaces where the issue should be explored in depth and where we could study ways in which the programme could contribute to finding solutions.

Continue reading →

PARTICIPATORY EVALUATION AND SOCIAL LEARNING

A NEW EPISODE OF THE EVALPARTICIPATIVA PODCAST

We continue to share the knowledge and feelings of colleagues and friends who are leaders in participatory evaluation in Latin America and other regions as well. In these podcasts we want to give a close and human perspective, where evaluative practice is closely linked to the personal experiences, stories and territorialities of the interviewees.

Continue reading →

Quality criteria for monitoring in development cooperation

by Dagmar Schumann

The idea for the document shared in this post was first discussed during a conference on monitoring in Germany. Our objective was to identify literature on broadly applicable quality standards or criteria for monitoring that could be considered nearly universal in their validity and application. While such documents exist for evaluation and research, no comparable paper could be found for monitoring.

A team of experienced German consultants specialising in planning, monitoring, and evaluation undertook the task of carefully examining this knowledge gap and developing a detailed document in response. We started by asking ourselves what ‘effective’ monitoring looks like. The first step was to conduct an extensive literature review. Subsequently, we developed the document ‘Quality Criteria for Monitoring in Development Cooperation‘ based on a thorough qualitative analysis of all available information.

Continue reading →

ECUADOR AND ITS EXPERIENCE WITH PARTICIPATORY EVALUATION

by Joselyn Michelle Corrales Vallejo

In this post, I will share some key experiences from a participatory evaluation in Ecuador, including the selection of the intervention to be evaluated and the final presentation of results and recommendations. This participatory evaluation—the first of its kind by the Ecuadorian government—assessed the Ministry of Economic and Social Inclusion’s Servicio de Espacios de Socialización y Encuentro para Personas Adultas Mayores (Social Interaction Spaces for Older Adults).

Leading this participatory evaluation was an invaluable experience both personally and professionally. There were certainly challenges and concerns, but thanks to the dedication and training of a strong team, we were able to turn these obstacles into valuable lessons and best practices. My sincere thanks to everyone who helped and supported the initiative which began when I had the opportunity to learn about participatory evaluation processes in Mexico and Costa Rica through my involvement with EvalParticipativa

Continue reading →

Webinar ‘Transformation through evaluation’

Dialogues between Participatory Evaluation and the Gender Perspective

On 9 November, the webinar ‘Transformation through evaluation’ hosted a discussion on the intersection of participatory evaluation and the gender perspective. These two pillars are critical to the design of inclusive, equal and transformational evaluations.

The panellists explored various aspects of participation in evaluations, including gender and human rights perspectives, how these intersect, and the challenges that arise.

Continue reading →

Evaluating participation from a human rights perspective

by Solana Yoma

From very early on in my professional training, I saw human rights as a tool for challenging and transforming ethically unjust realities. Accordingly, when I graduated as a psychologist, I did not focus on addressing people’s suffering on an individual basis, but rather on understanding it in its collective dimension, designing strategies that sought to transform the social conditions that generate this discomfort.

This motivated my interest in integrating contributions from clinical psychology into the design, planning, implementation and evaluation of health policies, plans and programmes. Later, while working on my doctoral thesis, I set out to evaluate a mechanism for citizen participation in mental health from a human rights perspective, and there I identified a gap that I managed to fill with my research. In this post, I will talk about this modest contribution.

Continue reading →

PARTICIPATORY EVALUATION MANAGEMENT

A NEW EPISODE OF THE EVALPARTICIPATIVA PODCAST

We continue to share the knowledge and feelings of colleagues and friends who are leaders in participatory evaluation in Latin America and other regions as well. In these podcasts we want to give a close and human perspective, where evaluative practice is closely linked to the personal experiences, stories and territorialities of the interviewees.

In this episode, Regislany Morais, from Brazil, shares her experiences and lessons learned about the collaborative management of social evaluation instances. Regislany is a Social Worker, committed and passionate about evaluation and humanitarian causes. She has extensive experience with public policies in contexts affected by armed violence. Her lines of research and work articulate evaluation, participation, humanitarian action and public policy.

Listen to our podcast (in Spanish) on iVoox and Spotify. You can also watch it on YouTube.

EVALUATION EXPEDITION: THE INTERVENTION FOREST

A game to evaluate the quality and performance of an intervention

by Vanesa Castro

The Evaluation Expedition is a participatory tool that invites all stakeholders involved in a project to go on a journey through a symbolic forest which represents the complexity of an intervention. Along this journey, participants must respond to key questions that allow them to engage in a comprehensive reflection, dialogue and evaluation of their intervention.

We present here this new creation of EvalParticipativa, a game that promotes a collaborative atmosphere in which every voice is heard and valued, and in which the active participation of everyone is essential for learning and continual improvement of our interventions.

Continue reading →